×
×
homepage logo

Guest opinion: The evils of imperialism

By Rick Jones - | Mar 20, 2025

Photo supplied

Rick Jones

Imperialism occurs when one nation tries to control the people and resources of another nation to enrich itself. Imperialism has been the most important force in world history for at least five centuries. After Columbus came to America, Spain and other European nations made every effort to enslave or dominate other areas of the world. The enormous enrichment that Spain gained through the enslavement and genocide of the New World soon had other nations trying to enrich themselves by colonization.

The American Revolution (1775-1783) was a war against British imperialism. The radical leftist and republican Thomas Paine — who was the preeminent American author of that age — argued it was absurd that an island (Britain) should rule a continent (America). The revolution was largely precipitated when the London-based East India Tea Company, a giant trading monopoly, got a bail out from Parliament that lowered its taxes and gave it rebates. This enabled it to dump low-priced tea on the American market, which undercut both established merchants and smugglers.

Activists in Boston responded with corporate vandalism, dumping 342 chests of tea into the Boston Harbor. (The tea was destroyed — not stolen — so that the smugglers and established merchants could still make their sales.) The British Parliament then closed the port of Boston until the corporate vandalism was paid for. In less than two years, the revolution against British imperialism started in that area.

Within a decade after the American Revolution concluded. the U.S. Constitution was adopted, and this was enormously beneficial for merchants. Before its adoption, states were issuing paper money and imposing tariffs and there were no standardized weights and measures. The Constitution greatly reduced state power over economic matters so as to move the country toward becoming one large market.

From the beginning, the U.S. Navy was extremely helpful for U.S. businesses. In 1801, U.S. naval forces were sent to Tripoli, Libya. (The Marines’ Hymn begins, “From the halls of Montezuma to the shores of Tripoli.”) The U.S. Navy was essential for the U.S. businesses involved with foreign markets; in just the 1800s, military forces were sent abroad more than 100 times, not counting the Mexican-American War and the Spanish-American War.

In 1922, the Office of Naval Intelligence prepared a very straightforward bulletin titled “The U.S. Navy as an Industrial Asset.” This report detailed services rendered by the Navy in protecting American business interests and in seeking out commercial and investment opportunities that the Navy brings to the attention of U.S. businessmen.

Trump’s favorite president has been Andrew Jackson (1829 to 1837) — perhaps because he arrogantly defied the Supreme Court and often acted in a cruel and dictatorial fashion. He definitely was the dominant political figure of the 1830s. The record of that period shows U.S. military forces traveling thousands of miles to protect business interests of the capitalist class:

  • 1831-32: The Falkland Islands, to investigate the capture of three American sealing vessels and protect American interests.
  • 1832: Sumatra, to punish natives for depredations on American shipping.
  • 1833: Argentina. Forces were ashore at Buenos Aires to protect the interests of the United States.
  • 1835-36: Peru. Marines protected American interests during an attempted revolution.
  • 1836: Mexico, to help Texas.
  • 1838-39: Sumatra, to punish natives for depredations on American shipping.
  • 1840: Fiji Islands, to punish natives for attacking American exploring parties.

At the time the government was sending the military to distant lands, it did almost nothing for ordinary people, especially racial and religious minorities. In 1838, Missouri’s Governor Boggs issued an extermination order against members of a church, saying they must leave the state or be exterminated. When the leaders of that church later appealed for redress before the Senate Judiciary Committee, they were told that Missouri was within its rights because the Constitution only prohibits the national government — not the states — from targeting religions.

The U.S. Constitution enshrined federalism, which meant that almost all individual rights and liberties were enjoyed at the pleasure of one’s state. This federalism helped perpetuate terrible injustices against Irish Catholics and other religions and racial minorities; some state constitutions forbid Jews, Catholics and atheists from holding office. Some states even prohibited African Americans from setting foot in their state.

The year Jackson left office, an economic downturn began that lasted for six years. Millions struggled to find jobs and food, and the government gave them no help. The U.S. ruling class generally favored “limited government,” but they wanted a carved-out exception that enabled the U.S. government to protect merchant interests. They maintained that government assistance to the working class would encourage “dependency” and “weaken moral fiber.” Only after Franklin Roosevelt (1933 to 1945) assumed the presidency did the government show concern for ordinary people.

In 1846, the U.S. government launched an imperialist war against Mexico. The war was vigorously denounced by Abraham Lincoln and other anti-imperialists, but the U.S. acquired half of Mexico’s land. By the 1890s, the U.S. wanted to emulate and compete with its mother country, Britain, which had a global empire. For the U.S. to have such an empire, it would require coal stations in distant lands to refuel naval ships; the U.S. was able to take the Spanish empire in the Spanish-American war with only 379 battle deaths.

After quickly defeating Spain, the U.S. invaded the Philippines to crush their independence movement. This war was at least 10 times as deadly for the U.S. as the Spanish-American War had been. The U.S. was guilty of horrific war crimes; it slaughtered probably several hundred thousand poorly armed Filipinos. General Smith, who oversaw some of the operations there, told his men to take no prisoners and to kill “everything over 10.” The slaughter the U.S. inflicted was heavily condemned by Mark Twain and Harvard philosopher William James, who declared, “God damn the U.S. for its vile conduct in the Philippine Isles.”

Most Americans greatly underestimate the damage U.S. imperialism has done to the world. U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara (1961 to 1968) maintained the U.S. killed 3.4 million Vietnamese.

The population of Utah is 3.4 million; imagine losing every man, woman and child in this state.

George Orwell observed, “The nationalist not only does not disapprove of atrocities committed by his own side, but he has a remarkable capacity for not even hearing about them.” Nationalists condemn imperialism only when it is done by a nation other than their own. They are like the person who only sees wrongdoing in others and considers themselves perfect. (“The greatest of faults is to be conscious of none.” — Thomas Carlisle).

The authors of our Declaration of Independence were hostile to the nationalist approach; the first paragraph indicates “a decent respect to the opinions of mankind.” This approach leaves no room to judge matters of fact on the basis of one’s place of residence. Facts do not permit a Russian, or anyone else, to claim Ukraine caused Russia’s invasion of it three years ago. Unfortunately, nationalism has often given patriotism a bad name. Linus Pauling, one of the very few winners of two Nobel prizes, declared, “Patriotism is an acceptance of national immorality.” It’s shameful and embarrassing that Donald Trump, abysmally ignorant of history and apparently oblivious to the untold suffering that imperialism has caused, has turned his lusty eye toward Panama, Canada, Greenland and Gaza.

However much Trump has divided this country (about 49% consider him a uniter; and about 49% consider him a divider), it is likely that he will unite a world that will distance itself from the U.S. It seems safe to make four predictions: 1. Trump will worsen the economy. 2. Trump will worsen relations with U.S. allies. 3. Trump will blame the damage he causes on Joe Biden. 4. China, which has been gaining on the U.S. for several decades, will take advantage of this very unique situation and will become more powerful than ever and might even dethrone the dollar.

Rick Jones is a retired adjunct teacher of economics from Weber State University.

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today